Old Fashioned Southern Pecan Pie

This classic pecan pie has a rich, gooey center and packed with buttery pecans. This southern pecan pie is a delicious addition to your holiday dessert table.

You cant get anymore old fashioned than southern pecan pie! There's just something about a pecan pie that screams south in your mouth. Most people only have pecan pie around Thanksgiving or Christmas, but my family enjoys it year-round. 

I used to shy away from baking pecan pies because you can run can run into the problem of the pie not setting up or you end up with a hard center from cooking it too long. So it took a little practice and I finally got it right. 
The perfect pecan pie has a well-set gooey filling, toasted pecans and the right balance of sugar. 

I use Moonshine syrup (which is a combination of corn syrup and cane sugar) for to make my pecan pie, but you can also use light corn syrup, yellow label syrup or even honey.  I stumbled upon moonshine syrup at a local peach orchard and it really changed my pecan pie game.  

I wasn't sure what was in the syrup, nothing was listed on the label it just really peaked my curiosity. I took it home and made my favorite Pecan Pie recipe and Bam!!!!!! I had the best pecan pie I had ever made.  

THESE ARE THE INGREDIENTS YOU WILL NEED: Pie Crust (I use Pillsbury or Marie Callender) I know people think store bought crust is cheating, but it is dependable and so good. Pecan Halves, sugar, eggs, real butter, vanilla extract, moonshine syrup or cane syrup and salt.


Here is my beloved moonshine syrup, oh how I ♥ you.

Preheat oven to 350 degree and prepare the crust.

Cream (mix) the sugar and butter well in a medium sized mixing bowl.


Add syrup, salt, and vanilla. Mix again look it is already getting thick.


Add the eggs and mix.


Mix well and stor in pecans (save a few to place on top of pie after cooking).

Pour the mixture into unbaked pie crust being careful not to overfill the crust. Place the pie on a baking sheet to prevent spillover into the oven while the pie bakes. Bake until the top is brown, and the pie is set (about 45 - 55 minutes). Cover the crust with aluminum foil if browns to quickly.

Remove the pie from the oven and give it a slight shake back and forth. If there is a slight jiggle in the center of the pie, then the pie is done. Allow pie to cool completely before serving. 








29 comments

Lara said…
We love pecan pie here at our house, but now I am intrigued by this moonshine syrup. I'll have to start looking for it.
Anonymous said…
This is my favorite - reminds me of my grandmother!
I'm like you Tina, I love pecan pie any time of year! Does the Moonshine Syrup taste like honey at all? The color makes it sort of look like corn syrup with honey, or maybe molasses in it. I thought that they had to put that kind of stuff on the label!

Anyway, you pie looks perfect and delicious!! Send me over a slice!
Tina Butler said…
Lara I hope you can find it. I had never seen it until that paticular day. Cane syrup is a good substitution.

Kathy, the old time desserts and pies are my favorite.

Mary, it does not taste like honey, but has the color of honey. I do not detect a molasses flavor either. This was home canned at the Ham Orchard Farm in their own kitchen. Then sold at their farmers market. It is a home canning label so nothing is listed except the name just as it is in the picture on my post. I dont think if you home can something you have to list ingredients. I emailed them and they wont say what the ingredients are and I cannot find it online. All they said was cane syrup was the closest.
Joan said…
That looks awesome. Can we order the moonshine syrup online? I have never heard of it. That pie looks absolutely perfect, it set up just right.
Tina Butler said…
Joan I just sent them a email to see if it can be purchased online. I know you are a fellow Texan and have posted in the past you have been to Canton. Hams orchard it right in Terrell. Not sure how far it is from you. Maybe next time you make a trip to First Monday you can swing into Terrell.
sherri said…
This does look perfect and who would have known that MOONSHINE was the secret ingredient?!
Lisa said…
Thanks for the great tutorial!
Michele said…
I have never made pecan pie...With your recipe, there may be a first! Looks so yummy! Wish I could have a piece!
Melody said…
I've never made pecan pie, but it looks delicious. The whole pecans are totally speaking to me.
Heidi said…
My grandma makes the best pecan pie. Yours looks so yummy and gooey just like hers. I can't wait until the next holiday so I can get me a piece. You lucked out finding that moonshine syrup.
Tina Butler said…
The orchard just replied. They stated they do not do any online orders or ship any products out. She mentioned that cane syrup is a excellent substitute:

Cane Syrup: This Southern staple is made from the juice boiled down from sugar cane, similar to the way maple sap is boiled down to make maple syrup. Cane syrup is thicker, with more viscosity and tends to have a fuller, sweeter taste than corn syrup. (Brands Steens,Sorghum, & Gorgia Cane Syrup)
Unknown said…
Pecan pie says, "Ya'll come to my house." I rarely make it now that there are only two of us at home, but I sure do love it. When I do make it, I tend to make it in mini pie pans and share it with neighbors that way. I'm not familiar with the Moonshine Syrup, but I use cane syrup as you suggested. I also noticed your slow cooker steak recipe that was recently posted. I hope you will join with me in August when I begin hosting Crock Pot Wednesdays on August 5 at diningwithdebbie.blogspot.com. Thanks for your great directions, too.
Tracy Bentley said…
ohhh!!! How I love pecan pie. Instead of cake on my birthday I would rather have a pecan pie. I finally made my first ones last year at christmas. I did not realize how easy they are to make. Thanks for sharing.

happy cooking
tracy
Alisa@Foodista said…
I love pecan pie,they should sell moonshine syrup online!I'd love to guide our readers to your site if you won't mind.Just add your choice of foodista widget to this post and it's all set to go, Thanks!
Mrs. Rogers said…
Do you have a recipe for the moonshine syrup?
Tina Butler said…
Laura, I dont I purchased the syrup at our local peach orchard. I cant even find anything online on to what the ingredients are. Sorry.
Jan A said…
Years ago I was making pecan pies and didn't have enough light Karo syrup. I didn't want to go to the store so I added some honey to it. That was such a hit that I always substitute about 1/4 or more of the Karo with honey.
Carrie said…
Wow, your pie looks incredible!
bakes with love said…
Hey,
Just wanted to let you know this Southern Pecan Pie recipe is the best! I've had a recipe that i've used for years,most time my pie don't set up or they are dry from overcooking,,just about when I was going to call it quits on making pecan pies,I came across yours. So I tried it for Thanksgiving,first time it set up,I did just use the corn syrup,but OH MY, I feel in Luv with this recipe, so it's a keeper in my kitchen! Thanks again, for posting these recipes, keep up the good work!
Autum said…
I have stayed away from baking pies because I could never get the pie to set up. However, I tried this recipe and the pie set perfectly. It also tasted wonderful. I am making two for Thanksgiving. Thank you so much for sharing.
Prin said…
WOW! I am so glad I found this site! all the recipes I will ever need on the same site!! I was in the same predicament as JanA only all i had was light brown sugar. it was awesome! The brown sugar made the filling much more custardy. But now I'm about to go in the kitchen and make one with cane syrup as that is what i have today :)
melanie said…
This is the first time I have been on your site. We live in Texas and I am a stay at home mom. I love to cook for my family and your recipes are great. I can't wait to try some of them. My family and I have a garden every year and I can alot of our food. If you have a recipe on dill pickles, I would love to have it. Thank you for your site, keep up the good work,
Karen said…
I am actually making 2 of these as we speak.I did add 2 tbsp brown sugar for a little more color.Wish I had the moonshine syrup.I posted your recipe on my site and am adding your button.
http://weightlosskw.blogspot.com
Gramma Linda said…
I found a place online where you can get Moonshine Syrup!
Here is the link......
http://shop.sweetmomentsintime.com/
Grays-Best-Moon-Shine-Syrup-Moon-Shine.htm

I'm going to order some and bake your pie!!
Donna said…
I use a combination of Lyle's Golden Syrup and real Vermont or Canadian Maple Syrup (half and half ratio) as corn syrup/cane are difficult to find here in Europe...It really works and complements the pecans wonderfully!
Kuryakitty said…
Just found this site and I love it and wanted to pass on my mother's secret for her pecan pie. She ran out of karo syrup one year and all she had was the pancake syrup they make. Substituted the Karo Pancake Syrup for the regular syrup and what a wonderful find! I will look for the moonshine syrup and try that. Thank you!
Anonymous said…
I JUST LOVE LOVE LOVE THIS RECIPE! I WAS VERY YOUNG WHEN ME AND MY HUSBAND GOT MARRIED AND DID NOT KNOW HOW TO COOK ANYTHING!! THESE RECIPES ARE GOOD AND VERY EASY TO FOLLOW WITH ALL THE PICS AND INFO! THANKS FOR POSTING THEM AND ONCE AGAIN WE JUST LOVE THE PECAN PIE!!
Anonymous said…
My granny used to make her pecan pie with moonshine syrup. She got it at pretty much any grocery store in North Louisiana. Hope that helps.