Old Fashioned Banana Cream Pie, Oh My!

Old Fashioned Diner Style Banana Cream Pie. 🍌 Scratch Vanilla pudding, layered with bananas and topped with a fluffy meringue topping!
The other day I posted a teaser photo on face book of the banana cream pie that I made. I try not to post too many teaser photos because I know everyone wants a recipe after seeing a photo. Usually 9 times out of 10 I am nowhere near ready to post it yet. I had also mentioned that I would be posting the recipe later in the week.

Well, a promise is a promise so here it is my favorite Old Fashioned Banana Cream Pie. I have said it before and I will say it again. I'm a sucker for a good old fashioned custard style pie. I just can't help myself, especially the diner style pies those are my all time favorite ones.

I found this recipe over 20 years ago and it's been my favorite banana cream pie ever since. You can also make just a plain vanilla cream pie by just leaving out the bananas. I also don't make a traditional meringue with egg whites. Because I can never make the meringue without it separating.

So to solve that problem I use my trusty meringue powder to make all my pies that require a meringue topping. When I use meringue powder my pies taste just like the ones from a bakery. Also if you don't like raw eggs then this would be a perfect substitution. 

I think I have just about baked and blogged about all my favorite pies here on Mommy's Kitchen. I still have a few up my sleeve to make because you can never have enough pie's can you? Let's get started and I will show you how easy this pie is to make.

Start by pre baking your pie crust. While it cools you can prepare the custard filling. Whisk together the milk, cream, and egg yolks. Combine the sugar and the cornstarch in a heavy saucepan. Whisk in the milk mixture and cook over medium heat, stirring constantly for 5 minutes. After 5 minutes stir the mixture constantly until it comes to a boil , about 5-7 minutes. Boil and stir the mixture for one minute.

The pudding mixture should be thick enough to coat the back of a spoon. Remove the saucepan from the heat and stir in the vanilla extract and butter. Let the filling sit a bit until it cools down some before adding the sliced bananas.

When cooled down add the sliced bananas and pour into the pie shell and smooth. Prepare the meringue topping and spread over the pudding. Place the pie in your ovens broiler and slightly brown the meringue. Watch carefully because it only takes a couple minutes.
Ok let's talk meringue. To get the perfect meringue topping I use my trusty meringue powder. The reason I like to use Meringue powder is because my meringue topping turns out perfect every time.

Just look at the picture above it's perfection. Sometimes when using eggs whites they don't set up or if you get any part the egg yolk in them it ruins and then the meringue separates all over your pie.

 So to solve that problem I use meringue powder for perfect meringue every time. I purchase mine at Wal-mart for $4.50 for the smallest can.

Believe me you get a lot of pie toppings from just one small can so don't buy the big one. One recipe only requires 1 tablespoon of meringue powder.

You can find meringue powder in the cake decorating isle. Click here for a link to my chocolate pie recipe and you can see a photo of what the meringue powder looks like.

Bam!!!!!!!!!! I don't know why I said that but that is what I said when I took it out of the oven after I browned the meringue! I feel so Emeril when I do that LOL.

Look how pretty that meringue topping is? Like I said perfection every time. If you want a pretty diner style pie then you need to be using the meringue powder.

Old Fashioned Banana Cream Pie


2 1/2 - cups 2% or whole milk
1/4 - cup heavy cream
2 - egg yolks
2/3 - cup sugar
4 - tablespoons cornstarch
2 - teaspoons vanilla extract
2 - tablespoons butter, room temp
1 - 2 ripe banana, sliced (not over ripe)
1 - 9 inch pie shelled, baked (homemade or store bought)
1 - 2 recipes meringue topping using meringue powder

Let's start by getting the pie crust prepared. You can prepare a homemade one crust recipe or use store bought pie crust.

Prick the bottom and sides of your pie crust and bake until golden brown. Remove from oven and let cool while you prepare the filling. Whisk together the milk, cream, and egg yolks.

Combine the sugar and the cornstarch in a heavy saucepan. Whisk in the milk mixture and cook over medium heat, stirring constantly for 5 minutes.

After 5 minutes stir the mixture constantly until it comes to a boil , about 5-7 minutes. Boil and stir the mixture for one minute. Remove the saucepan from the heat and stir in the vanilla extract and butter.

Let the filling cool down a bit before adding the sliced bananas. When cooled, add the sliced bananas and pour into the pie shell and smooth.
Prepare the meringue topping and spread on top of the pudding mixture.

Place under your ovens broiler for a couple minutes to brown the meringue topping. Make sure to watch carefully because it only takes a couple minutes. 

After baking, cool on the counter one to two hours and then place in the refrigerator uncovered for at least 3-6 hours before serving. 

Meringue Topping:

1 - 2 recipes meringue topping using meringue powder. Follow the directions on the back of the can of the Meringue Powder for Meringue Pies. I double the meringue recipe. It is the perfect amount for pies. The ingredients required will be meringue powder, sugar and water.


LeaAnn said…
I tried the meringue powder this week and it takes a ton on mixing before it sets up. Do you have any tips? I tried it by hand once and with a stand mixer the next time. It did look pretty though when I doubled the recipe and finally got it to set up.
Tina Butler said…
It does take a bit of time to get it to set up. Not more than about 10 - 12 minutes. Patience is the key. I use my stand mixer so it can whip away and I don't have to sit and baby it. In the end it is so worth it. My husband says it's the best meringue he has ever tasted.
Sara said…
This looks so good I think I gained 10lbs just reading about it. :)
Cassandra said…
Mmmm This looks yummy. Bet my hubby would love this.
ann said…
This pie looks fantastic! So good. It may be beyond my expertise!
Lisa said…
That pie is so delicious looking. I definitely want to try making this for my family the next time I'm home.
Amy said…
Wow, I want a piece of this pie NOW! :P

I'm hosting the very first GIVEAWAY on my blog. Please stop by to submit an entry. Good Luck! http://utry.it/2011/01/happy-birthday-to-meand-very-first.html
Lindsay Rudolph said…
I love any banana dessert and this one looks amazing! If I give it a try, I will most defintely let you know! Thanks for sharing.
gld said…
So, what do you do with the egg whites left from the pie?

The pie looks delicious and the whole technique is quite different from what I do....interesting.
Karen McIntosh said…
Just made this pie. All I can say so easy and delicious. I love Paula Deen also.Thank You So Much 4 The Recipe
Lety said…
Hello, I just found your blog today, I was looking for a banana cream pie recipie, and I found you. Let me tell you I just made this pie, and it is AMAZING!!!!, I used the meringue standard recipie and it turned out so good, I also made another pie, Paula Dean´s Pumpkin pie, wich is also amazing. I have a picture of both pies (not a very good one, but still works)If you like I could send them to you. Thank you! A BIG THUMBS UP FOR YOUR BLOG.
Anonymous said…
I made this pie and it is delicious. However for some reason it didn't set well at all it was runny and I let it cook long enough to coat the back of the spoon. What did I do wrong? ! The only thing I didn't do was the mering part of it!
Anonymous said…
Anonymous said…
ed-solution.uk.com [url=viagra-uk.org] viagra.uk.net[/url] viagra shipped from uk pdecg http://viagrawithout-prescription.net [url=http://viagra-canada.com[/url] how to buy cialis in canada viagra canda yqncskn xtmvjr http://viagra-cheap.org http://viagra-cheap.org generic viagra in canada viagra online pharmacy no prescription http://viagraonline.cc buy viagra online
Anonymous said…
Is riskless investment a dream or Utopia? It is not! Riskless investment is reality!

Never had there been such things at the financial market!

The unique program [url=https://en.milltrade.net/asset-management/mill-invest/?ref=527cb70fac928ed225000003]Mill-invest[/url] from «Mill Trade» exploded Internet! Even skeptics have invested in Mill-invest, as income does not depend on any outer conditions. The «Mill Trade» company is completely responsible for insurance of risks. Formal contracts are made.

[b]Attention, important figures: [/b]

Level of income – [b]7% guaranteed every month for each investor![/b]
3000$ - minimum deposit, profit is transferred to your account once a month — before the 7th day of the following month.

There is no need in any special knowledge in the field of investment or financial market.

What else do you need to start investment? Of course, you need a link to the official website of the «Mill Trade» company with corporate details for investment: [url=https://en.milltrade.net/asset-management/mill-invest/?ref=527cb70fac928ed225000003]program «Mill-invest»[/url]

This is the best offer for investment at the financial market in 2013! Following the results of the annual International Contest Global Banking & Finance Review, the «Mill Trade» company became the winner in the nomination «Best New Investment Program Russia & Eastern Europe 2013».

Invest your money into the program Mill-invest and every month in 2014, by making profit, satisfy yourself of your right decision!
Anonymous said…
[url=http://www.rougo-life.com/data/icon/prada-p-2.html]コーチ バッグ トート[/url] һ䣬˵ͣǾѾ֪˳ʱ ͰǾ˼˵L
ǣΪʲ首のくるぶしシャオシ自身を、アイソクロナѽֻаԺ˵ ˣߵԼֻみを伴う病気になりま[url=http://www.rougo-life.com/data/icon/louisvuitton-p-2.html]ルイヴィトン バッグ 新作[/url] は静かに耳を傾けた。 Ţټ½ÙݣͲ࣬ˡ
[url=http://www.seoul284.org/new/img/old/birkenstock-p-4.html]ビルケンシュトック 正規品[/url] 子は、彼女は私の目のオシャオチーNIEのȥˣȴ˵̫ˣΪʲÔأngkunjiaoオ李シャオNIEのNaonie足首シャオGͷèһ
ςһҲû[url=http://www.netz-kagoshima.jp/test/gucci-b-3.html]http://www.netz-kagoshima.jp/test/gucci-b-3.html[/url] uaixiaonie​​hangrn?
®ԼÛ൱ľкǿҵԸ 、私達の両方は、映画残る1は存在しない?くん謝くんくんくん猫Ôˡ
[url=http://yy-net.gr.jp/jimusyo/siryo/2012/celine-p-1.html]セリーヌ財布[/url] ˵˾䡰Σ˵ֵͷҲ Щ康を

今在はそれに慣れ。夏のャオNIEのNIEのそれが不経済費用対効ehuaixiao inkao Kunj[url=http://www.rougo-life.com/lib/webliberty/celine-p-2.html]セリーヌ バッグ 2014[/url] かった。彼女は主にこiaoniebaodからないが、あなたは

Anonymous said…
Hello My name id Jochua, and i wanna make big threaf here about all
last man standing is kill my brain
noe i present to all [url=http://pidarashechki23.com]http://pidarashechki23.net[/url]
Jen said…
My 91 year old grandpa has a story he tells of how his mother made the best banana cream pie. One summer she made one and dropped it on the front porch. He said he went out there with a fork and took care of that mess! I will be making this for him at our next get together. Never made, let alone tried, a banana cream pie. Thanks for the recipe!!
Anonymous said…
I want to try this for sure
Marianne said…
Is it possible to make pie filling using skim milk and extra butter?
Madison said…
I just made this pie and it was absolutely delicious! My family loved it and we will be making it again!
Tina Butler said…
I am so glad you liked it! Banana Cream Pie is one of my family's favorites. Thank you for stopping back by and letting me know.