Melt In Your Mouth Lemon Bars

These Luscious Lemon Bars have a buttery shortbread crust, a tangy melt in your mouth lemon filling and finished off with a simple lemon glaze. 
Lemon Bars are my daughters favorite sweet treat. This delicious bars have a buttery shortbread crust and a tangy lemony melt in our mouth filling. The crust is pre baked to ensure crispness. The filling uses fresh lemons, so don't try and substitute with bottled lemon juice, because they just won't taste the same. 

These lemony bars are super delicious and simple to make. I found the recipe back in 2000 in a Bisquick Cookbook that I received in the mail. At the time I was looking for a good lemon bar recipe, and I've been making this recipe ever since. 

You can tell by the photo above at just how many times I have made this recipe. Look at all those splatter marks! The original recipe called for low fat Bisquick and a egg substitute, but I use any brand biscuit baking mix and whole eggs. 

I did note at the end of this post the low fast substitutions from the original recipe. I also doubled the filling and glaze ingredients because I just felt like it it wasn't enough after the first time I made this recipe.  The recipe below reflects the change, so do not double the ingredients.

 I hope you enjoy these Lemon Bars as much as I do. 

Melt In Your Mouth Lemon Bars

1 - cup biscuit baking mix 
2 - tablespoons powdered sugar
2 - tablespoons firm butter

1 1/2 - cups sugar
2 - tablespoon biscuit baking mix
4 - whole eggs
1 - teaspoon grated lemon peel
4 - tablespoons lemon juice
1/2 - teaspoon lemon extract, optional 

1 - cup powdered sugar
2 - tablespoons lemon juice

Preheat the oven to 350 degrees. In a medium size bowl, mix 1 cup biscuit baking mix and powdered sugar. Cut in butter until it resembles crumbs. 

Press the mixture into an un greased 8 x 8 x 2 square baking pan. Bake the crust for 10 minutes or until very lightly brown. Remove from oven and set aside.  

In a separate medium size bowl, mix the filling ingredients and stir together using a wire whisk. Pour the lemon filling over the baked crust. 

Bake about 25 minutes or until the filling is set and lightly golden brown. Remove from oven and cool on a wire baking rack. 

While the bars are still warm, loosen the edges from sides of pan. In a small bowl, mix the glaze ingredients together using a wire whisk until smooth. 

Pour the glaze over the top of Lemon filling and spread to the edges. Cool completely, cut into bars.

Low Fat Version:
Substitute regular baking mix with Reduced Fat Baking Mix. Use a 1 cup Egg Substitute for to equal the amount for 4 whole eggs. Reduced fat butter can also be used. 

adapted from: Bisquick - bettycrocker
photos updated: July 2017

Pin to your favorite Pinterest Board 


Stephanie said…
Those look so good! I love the idea of using a glaze, instead of just sprinkling with powdered sugar like we usually do.
Tina Butler said…
Stephanie, the glaze takes them over the top good. I think thats the best part. Thanks for stopping by.
Michele said…
I have the same little cookbook...and I love, love, love those bars!! Now I'm craving one. :-)
Live.Love.Eat said…
Hmmmm, these look delish, I just wish I loved lemon sweets enough to actually make them. But I bet if I was there I would gobble up a few and love 'em!!!!
Anonymous said…
These bars look soooo yummy and easy! You always have such great recipes! Thanks so much Tina!
Laura said…
Those look too good. I'll have to save it for my to try list. I too like the glaze idea.
Tina Butler said…
Michele isnt that the best little cookbook! I would hate to loose my copy.

Live.Love.Eat Maybe these will Bars will change your mind on Lemons. They really are good.

anonymous, thanks for stopping by my site and thanks for the compliment on my recipes.

Laura, the glaze is so much better than regular powdered sugar. You will have to try it when you make them. I promise you wont be disappointed.
Anonymous said…
They were so good I'd never tasted anything like them before, I allmost didn't want to share =) thanks for the recipe
My mouth is watering. Watering....dare I look around more before lunch? :)
Hi Tina. Thanks for visiting. You want to make piloncillo bread and I want to make lemon bars. I love lemon pastry. You can get piloncillo at the supermarket in the Mexican food aisle or the imported food aisle. If your store does not carry it, gourmet sluth or mexgrocer carries it online. Let me know how it turns out.
Anonymous said…
Oh wow! My lemon bar recipe is different, but they both look the same. Either way, they're yummy as all get-out.
Shawna said…
These looks absolutely delectable!!! I have to make these soon!!!! YUM!
Danielle said…
OMG! Thank you. I'm going to make these now.
Annamarie said…
I'm new to your website and i really enjoyed making gooey cookies loved them!! I have a question on the lemon bars. do you cool the crust first before you pour the filling?
Yum! I've never seen a lemon bar using Bisquick and love that they have a glaze, too! :)
Anonymous said…
I did lose this cookbook in my last move and have grieved that I couldn't find this recipie. THANK YOU for taking the time to make it available to the rest of us. One of my very favorite recipies of all time.
Unknown said…
I am so happy you shared this recipe! I ❤ lemon bars!